Why Nervousness of Rupee's Fate Will Continue for Many Months

Rupee's rollercoaster ride continues. Down yesterday, and today first up down, up... Well, I am sure people will get the drift. Of course, the fear that the rupee will plumb the depths it had some months back is still fresh in people's minds. I have been asked a couple of times in the last two months, especially in a popular radio show, whether I expect a major turnaround in the fortunes of the rupee. My reply has always been been that it is unlikely that it will appreciate beyond Rs 60 to a dollar in the best case and in most days till March-end it will probably hover closer to Rs 60 than Rs 65. I do still believe so. As we move ahead in the remaining part of the financial year, we can expect exports to perk up as US and some European economies recover. If the gold imports remain in control as they have (the unofficial imports i.e. smuggling must be going on), this should be a decent factor helping the rupee. Inflation is unlikely to spike internally (monsoon is behind us) though it can remain stubbornly high at the current levels.That leaves us with US Fed's so-called "Tapering". It is unlikely that anything drastic will be done by Fed real soon. History teaches us that economies recovering after recession triggered off by a financial crisis take long time to recover and do so slowly. The current global financial crisis is no different. It has been six years since 2008. Median wages today in the US are what existed about four decades back and public investment is at the same level as 1947. These are not the indicators of an economy out on a hundred metre dash in the next few months raising inflation and employment levels which the Fed will be eyeing before it begins the "Tapering". Of course, that will not stop people from getting nervous about the rupee since confidence in a currency is also about the confidence in the economy it represents. One has to admit that India's fundamentals need to be fixed. A critical milestone will be the fiscal deficit figure that will be mentioned in the next Union Budget on February 28. Once the world has known that the Government has been able to meet its target (by hook or crook) and also has been able to control the external deficit, which I think it will be able to meet, people will start feeling a little less nervous about the rupee. But that's more than three months away, isn't it? Well, till then, we can expect more of the same.    

A Problem Called Europe

Uncertainty over events in Europe and its impact on the European crisis continues to take a toll across the globe. In India, its impact on stockmarkets this week is clearly visible where despite the Finance Minister's clarification on GAAR (which to some is "half-hearted", if not half-baked") there have been downward moves in the market and less-than-required-enthusiasm. To me, the "euromess" if I am allowed to coin this has two important messages. First, to enjoy economic benefits of a economic union you need to have monetary and fiscal policies both under single control. Minus the fiscal levers and fiscal discipline, it is not very difficult to get into the kind of mess Europe has got into. For instance, tt is now common knowledge that all the members of EU have flouted their fiscal deficit many times during the period the Union has been around. Included in the list is Germany which at times pontificates to other nations. If you take a step back and take a hard look, you will see similarities between and Europe and India as well. While India's monetary authority has been taking action in the recent past in India we don't find matching contribution by the government on the fiscal front.

The second lesson from Europe is the more worrying one. Recent elections have thrown out governments that have been following policies of economic austerity. While there are eminent economists such as Paul Krugman who feel that these policies should have not been initiated in the first place since what was required was more good old Keynesian government spending to create jobs and not worry about deficits and inflation as some governments have, the message from the electorate is that if a government's policy doesn't work for people, it will be thrown out. But can people throw out a system be thrown out if it doesn't work? History is replete with examples be it Germany in early 1930's or many others when demagogues seized power after thwarting democracy, free speech and free markets, encashing on people's desperation. In Spain, it seems about 50 per cent of the youth are unemployed. Anybody in the know of the economic situation can tell that the current euromess and global financial crisis will not go away in a hurry. Thus, while it will be easy for political parties and politicians to seize power encashing on popular disenchantment, it will not be easy to deliver the moon they promise as there are no easy ways out of the mess. The danger lies in people getting disillusioned with existing systems altogether and we will have a global cesspool. If one reads accounts of Greeks reeling under the impact of austerity measures one would start realising the meaning of "lost generation". While in US the situation is better thanks to a lower unemployment rate, but profound changes are already happening to people and their lives. Popular media is documenting how people even in their 70's are continuing to work sometimes at half the pay, because they can't afford to lead the retired life. The other scary lesson from anti-austerity movements is that once people get used to certain things they will not be able to live without them. It will be difficult for politicians to convince people on matters of economics. For instance, how will you convince people in India to pay user charges for electricity, cooking gas and diesel? Who can? Try telling this to our legislators who dole out one freebie after the other to the public as if there is no tomorrow.